Aviva vs Legal & General life insurance
A plain-English UK comparison of two of the country’s biggest life insurers in 2026: how their term, decreasing and over-50s cover lines up, what their published claims records look like, and the added-value health and support services that set them apart.
Aviva or Legal & General — what’s the difference?
- Both are major, long-established UK insurers offering very similar core cover — level and decreasing term life insurance, over-50s plans, and critical illness as an optional add-on.
- Both have strong published claims records. For 2025, Aviva reported paying 98.7% of life insurance claims and Legal & General reported 97.5% — both above the industry average.
- The clearest difference is the “extras”. Aviva includes its DigiCare+ health app (24/7 GP, second opinions, counselling); Legal & General includes nurse-led Wellbeing Support and a Care Concierge service.
- Price depends on you, not the brand. The cheaper insurer varies by age, health, cover amount and term — which is why comparing a like-for-like quote from both matters more than the logo.
Aviva vs Legal & General at a glance
| Feature | Aviva | Legal & General |
|---|---|---|
| Level term life insurance | Yes | Yes |
| Decreasing (mortgage) cover | Yes | Yes |
| Over-50s guaranteed-acceptance plan | Yes | Yes |
| Critical illness cover | Optional add-on | Optional add-on |
| Terminal illness cover | Included on eligible policies | Included free on policies with a term of 2+ years |
| 2025 life claims paid (published) | 98.7% — about £860m to 40,000+ families | 97.5% — about £527m across c.13,950 claims |
| Built-in extra services | DigiCare+ health app (24/7 GP, second medical opinion, counselling) | Wellbeing Support (RedArc nurses) and Care Concierge |
Indicative and for general comparison only — based on each insurer’s published 2025 claims statements and product information; features, eligibility and claims rates change year to year. Not a quote and not a recommendation of either insurer.
How the two compare on core cover
On the fundamentals, Aviva and Legal & General are closely matched. Both offer level term life insurance (a fixed lump sum over a fixed term), decreasing term designed to track a repayment mortgage, and an over-50s plan with guaranteed acceptance and no medical questions. With both, critical illness cover can be added for an extra premium, and terminal illness cover — which pays the sum assured early if you are diagnosed with an illness expected to cause death within 12 months — is built into eligible policies at no extra cost.
Because the building blocks are so similar, the practical decision usually comes down to the price for your circumstances and the small print — maximum ages, cover limits, how each insurer underwrites your health and occupation, and the optional benefits you bolt on. For a refresher on how these cover types and payouts work, see the life insurance hub, or our guides on mortgage life insurance and over-50s cover.
Claims records: both pay the vast majority
For life insurance, what ultimately matters is whether the insurer pays when a family claims. Both publish their figures each year. For 2025, Aviva reported paying 98.7% of life insurance claims — around £860 million to more than 40,000 families — while Legal & General reported paying 97.5% of life claims, around £527 million across roughly 13,950 payouts. Both sit above the long-standing industry average, and in both cases the small share of declined claims is driven mainly by misrepresentation — incorrect or undisclosed information at application.
The headline lesson is the same whichever insurer you choose: answer every health, lifestyle and occupation question fully and honestly. An accurate application is the single biggest thing within your control to make sure a claim is paid.
Where they differ most: the support services
The most visible difference between the two is the package of extra services bundled in at no extra cost. Aviva includes DigiCare+, a health and wellbeing app you can use from day one without making a claim — typically offering 24/7 access to a GP, mental-health counselling sessions, and a second medical opinion from a specialist if you receive a serious diagnosis, often extendable to your partner and children. Legal & General takes a more claims-time approach, including Wellbeing Support — personalised help from experienced nurses (provided via RedArc) covering illness, bereavement and mental health — alongside a Care Concierge service to help navigate later-life care.
Neither set of extras is “better” in the abstract: Aviva’s leans towards everyday health access, Legal & General’s towards support during the major events that lead to a claim. Which is more useful depends on what you value — it is worth weighing alongside the core price and cover, not instead of it.
How to choose between Aviva and Legal & General
Because both are financially strong, established insurers with similar cover and strong claims records, there is rarely a single “right” answer — the better-value option genuinely varies from person to person. The reliable approach is to decide how much cover and what term you need first, then get a like-for-like quote from both (and ideally other insurers too), comparing the total premium, the optional benefits included, and the small print on age and health limits. A premium that looks a few pounds cheaper can be the more expensive choice if the cover or terms differ. For more on getting the amount right, browse the life insurance hub and related guides, including cover for smokers.
Aviva vs Legal & General: FAQs
Information only — not financial advice and not a recommendation of any insurer or product. Figures are based on each company’s published statements, are indicative, and are not a quote; claims rates and product features change over time, so check the insurer’s current documents. My Insurance Expert is not an FCA-authorised intermediary and does not arrange or sell policies. Last updated: 2026-06-28
More Life Insurance pages
- Life insurance in trust
- Life insurance for a high BMI
- Life insurance for armed forces
- Life insurance with depression and anxiety
- Life insurance for cancer survivors
- Life insurance for sleep apnoea
- Life insurance with high blood pressure
- Life insurance for offshore workers
- Family income benefit
- Key person insurance
- Relevant life insurance for directors
- How much do I need
- Term vs whole of life
- Pre-existing conditions
- Life insurance for diabetics
- Life insurance over 65
- Over-50s, no medical
- Joint vs single
- Life insurance over 60
- Cost by age
- No medical exam
- Life insurance for smokers
- Mortgage life insurance
- Life insurance over 70